That is how I always saw it. Someone broke the neck of the bird...but during the kiss scene (that is just movie not book as well) there is a live bird in the cabinet. I thought why'd they kill the first bird, but not the second. So though I can't see the apple as anything but some guy took a bite out of it, I can see how the first bird was it not working and the second bird was it working. OR that second bird was sent from the shop, a new bird that Draco never put in their but the guy from the shop did. And Draco never got to release that bird, since Harry did. Does that mean that Draco wasn't even sure if the cabinet worked when he let the DE in? I don't know.
But I saw it the same way you saw when I watched it. It never occurred to me that anyone would see that in a different way. I thought it was obvious.
no subject
Date: 2013-10-12 09:44 pm (UTC)But I saw it the same way you saw when I watched it. It never occurred to me that anyone would see that in a different way. I thought it was obvious.